Intermittent Low Quality Power Pushing Europe Toward a New Dark Ages

The cost of US electric power is much lower than that of European competitors. This is because the US has been slow to adopt the “green energy swamp” approach to economic suicide which the Europeans seem determined to follow. As long as costs for US natural gas and electricity are appreciably lower than those of its competitors, the US will have a distinct advantage in manufacturing. Thus all the European manufacturers that have moved operations to the US to take advantage. __ Energy Costs Matter

The graph below appears benign enough, but it hides an ominous trend for Germany, Europe, and anywhere else that adopts the green energy paradigm.

The Decline of German Competitiveness in Industry and Commerce

The rise in energy costs (electricity and natural gas) for Germany represent a steady decline in competitiveness for German industry and commerce. German industries are moving overseas, jobs are being lost, Germany’s economic future is shrinking along with its population.

Much of this devastation of Germany’s economic future results from a lack of recognition of the fatal mismatch between power grids and intermittent, unreliable energy sources.

Most renewables advocates don’t appreciate the scope and scale of electricity grids, the difficulties intermittency creates, and the technical/ commercial inadequacies of electricity storage technologies other than PHS.

It is very unlikely that any grid storage solution (other than PHS where feasible) could ever practically cover the intermittency of high penetration utility scale wind and solar. Utility voices (like RWE and E.ON) charged with making electricity grids work seamlessly and reliably despite ever increasing renewable intermittency burdens are only starting to be heard. Those voices are very negative. It may not be until some grid goes dark because of intermittency (as increasingly uneconomic flexed conventional generation is shut in Germany and UK) that the general public will understand. Germany, UK, and California seem determined to run this unfortunate experiment for the rest of us. __ See entire article for supporting data and calculations

The entire green energy edifice is built upon false claims and wishful thinking. As a former advocate of big wind and big solar, Al Fin required a number of years to work through that wishful thinking and those false claims to the underlying reality. It is unlikely that most journalists, politicians, “environmentalists,” or academicians have the intelligence, integrity, or persistence to work through the logic of the green quagmire.

Germany’s neighbors are taking precautions against the coming cascading blackouts caused by Germany’s increasing over-dependence upon unreliable, poor quality, intermittent energy sources.

Notably, the Czech Republic seems to regard unplanned power flows from Germany as a serious national security risk. As reported by the German magazine Der Spiegel, the Czech national electricity transmission system operator CEPS announced investment of more than 72 million Euros in phase shifting transformers at the German-Czech border – expected to be operational in 2016 – in order to shield the Czech Republic from the real possibility of a potential future blackout (Read on the ABB website on how to control power flow with phase shifting transformers).___

Meanwhile, in the US, the climate inquisition has not been allowed to shut down all useful forms of energy. Hydraulic fracturing in the US helps to suppress prices of natural gas and electricity — thus attracting large numbers of manufacturers from around the world, especially Europe.

A recent report projected that the cost of manufacturing in the U.S. will fall below costs in China within the next three years, in large part due to the rise of fracking.

Wiser nations are turning toward advanced nuclear power and more economical sources of natural gas — rather than turning against affordable, high-quality energy — as Germany and much of western Europe is doing. High quality, low cost energy attracts industrial and commercial partners, and supports national and regional employment.

It is no accident that the same European nation — Germany — that has fallen for the green energy scam is also one of the foremost chumps for Kremlin political propaganda. It is Russia, after all, which finances a great deal of anti-fracking propaganda in the west, and provides under the table financial support for green lobbies in the west that fight against nuclear and hydrocarbon power in the political arena. Germany was already dying, demographically. Energy and economic suicide by Germans will not make much difference in Germany’s ultimate fate.

After the massive death and devastation in Europe caused by Germany in the 20th century, it may be difficult for many outsiders to feel sympathy for the nation that did more than any other (except perhaps Russia) to devastate European demographics.

It is unfortunate that Germany is pulling the rest of Europe down with it in its hasty slide to self-destruction. When Europe goes dark, the collateral damage is likely to be grave.

The actual trends will be more striking than portrayed above, and will leave Germany at a much greater disadvantage when compared to North America, East Asia, and perhaps Oceania — if Australia and New Zealand can escape the green quagmire that has captured western Europe and Brussels.

Energiewende Disaster

Energiewende is a Permanent Disaster

Whose Fault is this Disaster?

Two German chancellors must share the blame: Schroeder and Merkel. Schroeder has long been in the pay of Russia’s Putin, so it is no wonder that he would promote a deliberate weakening of Germany’s energy supplies to the advantage of Russia, as Germany’s main gas supplier.

Merkel had adopted a wiser approach to Germany’s energy future — until the Fukushima tsunami and quake. After Fukushima, Merkel unwisely chose to opportunistically adopt Schroeder’s timeline to close Germany’s nuclear power plants — helping to trigger the current growing disaster.

Thus Merkel inadvertently jumped into bed with the crooked Schroeder, and caused herself and her country a host of preventable problems.

Time is running out for Germany’s opportunity to step back from the precipice.


1) Renewable energy is expensive. Any country that attempts to raise its contribution from renewable resources is going to end up paying higher prices. This is also visible in California, which has the highest percentage of renewables in the continental United States and also pays the highest electrical bills west of New Jersey.

2) Advancing renewables will require a series of regulatory rules that give special consideration to renewables while failing to reward the reliability of other generating sources.

3) At a certain point, the intermittency of renewable sources will threaten the dependability of the grid. Special measures will be required to prevent the problem from spreading to other regions.

Other than that, Germany’s Energiewende seems to be doing just fine [!} __

An excellent summing up. In other words, to keep the lights on and the future in play, “green energy” idiocy will have to be fended off at all costs.

This entry was posted in Electrical Power Grid, Energy, Europe, Germany, Green Quagmire and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Intermittent Low Quality Power Pushing Europe Toward a New Dark Ages

  1. Abelard Lindsey says:

    The part about the U.S. is good. Even if Clinton or some other democrat gets elected in ’16, they are unlikely to be able to shit down the fracking revolution in the U.S. Also, its looking like Congress will become even more GOP in ’16 as well.

    The fracking revolution, combined with automation/robotics/3-D printing (including the efforts of yours truly) will drive a manufacturing renaissance in the U.S. This, in turn, will be supplemented by some form of fusion power by the mid 20’s (there are enough start-ups such as Tri-alpha as well as LENR that one or more of them will be successful). I think the U.S. will do OK over the next 20 years.

    Europe is toast. I think we all agree about this.

    I think China will actually do OK over the next 20 years as well. Sure, they have their problems, with their culture of corruption being at the top of the list. However, they do actually try to make the right moves even if it is executed in a half-assed fashion. Remember, lots of bad things happened in the U.S. during the 1850-1950 period, including 7 depressions (yes, with a “D”), a lack of objective rule of law (what do you think the vigilantes were about in the old West?), and assorted other crap. Yet, the U.S. came out on top by 1950. It seems to me that the Chinese will experience all sorts of problems and setbacks from time to time, but still continue to move forward over the next few decades.

    The point is that all of the decentralizing technologies (3-D printing, bio-engineering, etc,) can be developed in this time period so that when a major crunch does come, say 2050 or so, the competent, intelligent people of the world will have our immortality and the ability to create our own manufacturing infrastructure (if necessary) so that we can go our own way (ocean cityp-state to start with – space colonization later on) completely autonomous and independent from those who might want to f**k with us.

    This should be our vision, our goal, of all “right” thinking peoples’ around the world.

    • alfin2101 says:

      As things are developing, it looks as if China will annex more of the Russian Far East within the next 20 years. China’s demographic crisis will not fully hit until around 2035 to 2040, which will give Putin plenty of time to turn Russia into an empty shell.

      The parts of Europe that turn away from Brussels-style leftygreen multiculti suicide have a good chance to survive and prosper — as long as they are prudent in their international alliances.

  2. yargo says:

    already impacting high precision machinery are increased fluctuations of the grid frequency, akin to “micro” brown-outs, which need additional equipment to deal with. nat gas power plants are being priced out by solar and wind and shut down, even though their ability to provide for peak load and keep grid frequency steady are crucial. for example irsching power plant at one point utilized the largest and most efficient gas turbine in the world but is now shut down.

Comments are closed.